As Mark Twain wisely quipped, “The secret of getting ahead is getting started.” Well, fans of Yellowstone might just find that the silver lining is

a whole lot shinier now that John Dutton, played by the legendary Kevin Costner, is riding off into the sunset. Sure, it’s sad to see him go, but

let’s be real—his departure could be just what the show needs to shake things up!

For those living under a rock (or maybe just binge-watching the same series for the tenth time), Yellowstone chronicles John’s relentless fight to preserve his family ranch. Seriously, this guy has sacrificed just about everything, including his own health. But now, as Costner decides to hang up his cowboy boots ahead of the second half of season 5, it raises the question: what happens next?

John Dutton Rides Off: What’s Next for Yellowstone?

As we gear up for what might be the grand finale of Taylor Sheridan’s neo-Western saga, it’s clear that John Dutton’s exit is a potential golden opportunity for the rest of the cast. Let’s be honest; they’ve been playing second fiddle for too long! Ergo, viewers are hoping that with Kevin Costner, 69, leaving, the other characters will finally get their chance to shine.

Whether it’s the fierce Beth, the charming Rip, or even the troubled Jamie, they all have stories that need telling. As one fan agreed and said:

Meanwhile, one fan raised some eyebrows over how John’s character transformed from a tyrannical patriarch into a sweet, cuddly teddy bear. Let’s take a stroll down memory lane! In the early seasons, Costner’s character is a hard-nosed leader, shaped by a rough past. He was a tyrant, sure, but he had depth.

Fans were hoping the show would’ve dug into those darker layers, letting John confront his childhood traumas and tackle the mess that is his family dynamics. Instead, they feel the writers opted for a shiny polish, transforming him into the kind of loving grandpa who bakes cookies instead of making tough decisions:

Fans are disappointed that the show has glossed over John’s past flaws, missing out on exploring the complexities of a flawed villain trying to navigate family chaos. Instead, it’s become more of a family sitcom—complete with heartwarming moments and all!

Let’s see what others are saying:

That being said, as we prepare to bid adieu to John, let’s raise a toast to new beginnings. The other characters are ready to break out of their shells and bring us some real growth.

How Could Taylor Sheridan Write John Dutton Out of the Show?

Let’s face it: Yellowstone’s John Dutton isn’t exactly the type to cut and run when things get tough. He’s not the guy who would leave his family to clean up the mess he’s made. So, it seems likely that a dramatic exit is on the horizon. And honestly, is there any other fitting way for a character like him to go out? Whether it’s a showdown in a shootout or a final bout with the cancer, it’s time for John to make his grand exit at the end of season 5.

Imagine that after five seasons of blood, sweat, and a healthy dose of drama, John’s death could open up a whole new chapter for Yellowstone. His kids and grandkids would be left grappling with their grief and trying to figure out what the future holds for the ranch without their fearless leader.

Also, there’s something poetic about the idea of him succumbing to cancer instead. After all, this was introduced way back in season 1, and closing that loop would give viewers a sense of closure—or at least a good reason to reach for the tissues.

Plus, it would set the stage for some epic character development, especially for Beth. Just think about it: her reaction to his actual death will surely be a wild ride compared to the grief she felt when she thought he was dying at the end of season 1.

Here’s to John Dutton—may his exit be as memorable as his reign over the ranch!