Fans Are FURIOUS 😡 Over Who Might Return in 6666 Spin-Off After Yellowstone S5 Finale – Did YOUR Favorite Make the Cut

As the curtain prepares to fall on Yellowstone Season 5, fans are not just preparing for emotional goodbyes — they’re gearing up for a new chapter in the Yellowstone universe. The much-anticipated 6666 spin-off, which has been teased for years, is finally gaining momentum. But as casting rumors swirl and hints drop from creators and cast members alike, one thing is becoming crystal clear: not everyone is happy with who may — or may not — be part of this next saga. And yes, fans are absolutely fuming.

The 6666 ranch — pronounced “Four Sixes” — has long been part of the Yellowstone lore, representing a rough-and-tumble world of Texas cowboys, gritty labor, and unrelenting survival. Unlike the Dutton family’s sprawling Montana empire, the Four Sixes runs on sweat, loyalty, and tradition. So naturally, viewers expected some familiar faces to make the jump. However, not all favorites are making the cut, and social media is blowing up with frustration, disbelief, and even boycotts.

Let’s break down what we know — and what has fans so upset.

Jimmy’s Return Is Confirmed… But Is It Enough?

Jefferson White’s portrayal of Jimmy Hurdstrom has been one of the most transformative character arcs in the Yellowstone universe. From troubled ranch hand to skilled cowboy, Jimmy’s journey to the 6666 ranch in Season 4 was seen as a turning point — and a backdoor pilot for the new spin-off. Now, it’s officially confirmed that Jimmy will return in 6666. But while some fans are thrilled, others feel like his character alone can’t carry the emotional weight of the new show.

“Jimmy is great, but he’s not the reason I fell in love with Yellowstone,” one fan posted on Reddit. “If Rip, Beth, or even Walker don’t show up at the 6666, I’m not watching.”

Others echo this sentiment, saying Jimmy’s story feels too neatly wrapped up — and bringing him back just for the sake of connection feels forced.

Where’s Rip? Fans Demand Answers

Perhaps the biggest controversy is the uncertain fate of Rip Wheeler, played by Cole Hauser. Rip has been a fan-favorite from day one — a rugged, loyal, deeply complex character whose love story with Beth Dutton is the emotional backbone of the series.

When Rip was sent south in the back half of Season 5 to help out on the Texas ranch, many fans assumed it was a transition to the 6666 spin-off. But now, insiders suggest Rip’s stay might be temporary — and that he won’t be a permanent fixture in the new show.

This revelation has sent shockwaves across the fanbase.

“You take Rip out of Yellowstone and out of the spin-off? What are you even doing?” one Twitter user fumed. “No Rip, no watch.”

Others argue that Rip deserves more than just a passing cameo in 6666 — especially after years of character development. Many are holding out hope that the creators are just keeping his role a surprise to avoid spoilers.

Beth Dutton — No Plans to Appear

Kelly Reilly’s Beth Dutton is, without a doubt, one of the most iconic and polarizing characters on television today. Her sharp wit, fearless attitude, and emotional vulnerability have made her a standout across Yellowstone’s run.

And yet — there are currently no plans for Beth to appear in 6666. This news has fans practically rioting online.

“Beth is Yellowstone,” one Facebook group moderator wrote. “Why start a spin-off without the woman who helped define the tone of the show?”

To be fair, Beth’s story is heavily tied to the Dutton family and their Montana roots. Moving her to Texas might feel unnatural — but that hasn’t stopped fans from demanding at least a cameo.

Walker Might Make the Leap — But It’s Not Confirmed

One name that keeps popping up in speculative forums is Walker (Ryan Bingham), the wandering musician with a troubled past. His roots in Texas make him a strong candidate for 6666 — and his chemistry with other ranch hands could add flavor to the new cast. But as of now, there’s no official word on whether he’ll appear.

Some fans say including Walker would be a smart way to bridge the worlds, while others think his storyline has run its course. Still, in a show that’s leaning heavily on authenticity and grit, Walker’s musical soul might be just what the Four Sixes needs.

New Faces, Old Problems?

While longtime fans of Yellowstone are mourning the absence of beloved characters, 6666 is reportedly introducing a whole new roster of faces. Early casting leaks suggest the focus will be on new ranch hands, local law enforcement, and Texas-based legacy families who run the cattle business with old-school ruthlessness.

That’s exciting for newcomers — but for diehard fans, it’s risky. Many fear the heart of Yellowstone will be lost if 6666 leans too far into unfamiliar territory.

“It’s starting to feel like a completely different show,” one YouTube commenter lamented. “I wanted a spin-off, not a reboot.”

What Taylor Sheridan Has to Say

Series creator Taylor Sheridan, who also owns the actual 6666 ranch in real life, has remained mostly tight-lipped about casting specifics. However, in a recent interview, he hinted that the spin-off will “stand on its own” while “respecting the legacy of what came before.”

That’s a delicate balance — and one that has fans anxiously waiting for more details.

“Respecting the legacy” is one thing, but for many viewers, that means more than just naming a character or two from the original show. It means continuity, emotional connection, and payoff after years of investment.

Final Thoughts

As Yellowstone winds down with its final episodes, the spotlight turns to 6666 — and for many fans, that spotlight is burning hot. The absence of key players like Rip, Beth, or even Kayce has created a wave of disappointment and anger online. While Jefferson White’s Jimmy will return, it remains to be seen whether one beloved cowboy is enough to anchor an entire universe.

For now, viewers are holding their breath — and voicing their fury. Because when it comes to the Yellowstone legacy, fans want to see the characters they’ve loved, fought for, and cried over. And if they don’t, they’re not afraid to walk away.

Will 6666 rise to the occasion? Or will it fall flat without the heart and soul of the Dutton dynasty?

Stay tuned — and saddle up. The ride is far from over.