The gripping Emmerdale storyline surrounding Anthony Fox’s impending death has taken another twist, with fans eagerly analyzing every clue to figure out what happens next.

A key moment that has got viewers buzzing is the appearance of a mysterious human tooth in a recent episode, sparking intense speculation about whose it might be.

While many initially thought the tooth could belong to Anthony himself, it seems the truth might be far more unexpected.

Fans have begun to theorize that the tooth might not belong to Anthony Fox at all – and it could point to a shock return for a much-loved character.

The Suspense Builds: The Tooth Mystery

The mystery of the human tooth first came to light in a tense flash-forward scene during Monday night’s episode.

As the camera zoomed in on a lifeless Anthony lying in a pool of blood in the depot, the tooth caught viewers’ attention. With Anthony’s fate already sealed in the storyline, the question arose: Who does this tooth belong to?

While many fans immediately associated the tooth with Anthony, given that it was discovered during the buildup to his death, some sharp-eyed viewers began to question if there was more to this clue than meets the eye. Could the tooth belong to someone else? With Emmerdale’s knack for dramatic twists and surprises, fans quickly began speculating on an unexpected character who might be linked to this gruesome clue.

The Shocking Theory: Could It Be Nate Robinson’s Tooth?

As the mystery deepened, one fan theory started to gain traction: Could the tooth actually belong to Nate Robinson, the former Emmerdale character who left the village under mysterious circumstances last year?

Nate, played by Jurell Carter, left the Dales in a rather understated manner, after being accused of kissing Moira Dingle (Natalie J Robb). His departure was abrupt and unexplained, with many fans feeling that there must be more to his exit than what was shown on screen. Given the shocking developments surrounding Anthony’s death, it seemed like the perfect time for a return, and the discovery of the tooth has only fueled this speculation.

A number of fans took to social media, especially within Emmerdale fan groups, to discuss the possibility that the tooth might be Nate’s. One fan posted, “I really think the tooth is Nate’s… he went several months ago and hasn’t been heard from since.” Others quickly joined the conversation, expressing similar thoughts. “That would be some twist!” another fan added, highlighting just how surprising and thrilling such a development would be.

The Link to Nate’s Sudden Exit

Nate’s departure from the show was marked by a shocking accusation, but his final moments in the village were conspicuously quiet. Fans were left wondering if Nate’s storyline would eventually come back into play, especially given the unresolved nature of his exit. The theory that Nate might be linked to Anthony’s death, especially in connection to the mysterious tooth, would certainly add a thrilling layer to the ongoing drama.

Nate’s return would also create further intrigue for Emmerdale viewers. If the tooth did belong to him, it could indicate that his character played a hidden role in Anthony’s violent end. Perhaps Nate had been secretly lurking in the background, waiting for the right moment to strike – or maybe he became an unwitting victim of the violence.

Could This Be a Set-Up for Nate’s Comeback?

The idea that Nate could be involved in Anthony’s death brings another compelling element to the mystery. If it turns out that the tooth does indeed belong to Nate, the storyline could set the stage for a shocking return, with Nate being revealed as either a suspect or an unfortunate casualty in the aftermath of Anthony’s violent end.

Given that Nate had unresolved tensions with several Emmerdale characters before he left, including his rocky relationship with Moira and the Dingles, his return could lead to some explosive confrontations. Could Nate have had a hidden motive for seeking revenge on Anthony? Or could he have been caught up in the chaotic events that led to Anthony’s demise?

What’s Next for Emmerdale Fans?

As the mystery continues to unravel, Emmerdale fans are on the edge of their seats, eagerly awaiting the next twist. Will Nate make a dramatic return? Is the tooth a clue that will unlock a whole new layer of the murder mystery? Or is it simply a red herring to throw viewers off course?

With Emmerdale known for its unpredictable storytelling and jaw-dropping moments, it’s safe to say that fans are in for an exciting ride. Theories about Nate’s involvement, or the real identity behind the tooth, will keep viewers guessing as the drama builds towards its shocking conclusion.

Whether or not Nate’s return is in the cards, one thing is certain: Emmerdale will continue to deliver high-stakes drama that keeps fans captivated and on their toes. The question now is, who will be next to face the consequences of the village’s dark secrets?