Emmerdale has left fans on the edge of their seats with its latest gripping episode,

which revealed a chilling discovery

beneath the frozen lake.

The shocking scenes on Monday’s show saw Amy Wyatt (Natalie Jamieson) trapped under the ice, but as rescuers worked to save her, viewers spotted another body submerged in the water.

Now, speculation is rife about the identity of the second body, with many fans convinced it could be the long-missing Nate Robinson (Jurell Carter), who left the village last year.

The Body Beneath the Ice: Who Is It?

The haunting discovery has left fans scrambling for clues about who might be the unfortunate soul found beneath the frozen surface.

While Amy’s perilous situation was at the forefront of Monday’s episode, it was the glimpse of the second body that has caught the attention of viewers.

As Amy struggled to free herself from the icy depths, another body could be seen lying motionless in the water.

One of the key hints that has fueled theories is a bracelet Amy notices on the submerged body. The bracelet appears to be identical to the one Frankie (who crafted it for Nate) gave to Nate Robinson. This has led many fans to believe that the body could indeed be Nate’s, despite his departure from the village for Shetland months ago.

John Sugden’s Suspicious Behavior: A Link to Nate?

The mystery surrounding the body has also sparked renewed interest in John Sugden (Oliver Farnworth), who has become a key figure in the speculation. John’s involvement in Nate’s departure has been called into question, especially after his conversation with Tracy (Amy Walsh) about Nate’s sudden exit. John highlighted that Nate never said goodbye to his daughter Frankie, which raised suspicions that not all was as it seemed regarding his departure.

Some fans have gone further, suggesting that John may have played a role in Nate’s disappearance. One theory gaining traction is that John might be involved in Nate’s fate and possibly even responsible for his death. Could John have had a darker hand in the events leading up to Nate’s exit? Theories that John may be the one to have disposed of Nate’s body have caused quite a stir among the Emmerdale fandom.

Was It Caleb? Or Something More Sinister?

Another fan theory centers around Caleb (William Ash), with some viewers suggesting that Nate’s death could have been tied to an argument with Tracy. As Tracy and Nate had an on-again, off-again relationship, it’s not out of the realm of possibility that Caleb could have been involved in some way. Some fans are convinced that Caleb might have had a motive to harm Nate, leading to his death and eventual disposal of his body.

One fan even posited, “I think it will come out that Caleb killed him for what went off with Tracy,” hinting that jealousy or anger over Tracy’s relationship with Nate could have led to a tragic outcome. But is Caleb really capable of something so violent? Emmerdale fans are left questioning just how deep this plot goes.

Theories on Multiple Bodies and Anthony’s Connection

As the mystery deepens, some fans are suggesting the lake could be hiding more than one body. Another theory circulating among viewers is that Nate isn’t the only one who could be submerged beneath the ice. Fans have pointed out the possibility that Anthony Fox (Nicholas Day), Ruby’s (Beth Cordingly) father, could also be linked to the lake, especially given the ongoing mystery surrounding his death.

One fan speculated, “Nate was in that lake and I’m convinced it was John who put him there alongside Anthony.” This theory suggests that John may be responsible for multiple deaths, raising the stakes even higher. Could John be hiding a deadly secret, or is there someone else with a more sinister agenda? With so many unanswered questions, the intrigue surrounding the frozen lake continues to grow.

John Sugden: The Killer in the Dales?

The most popular theory among fans, however, is that John Sugden could be hiding something much darker than anyone realizes. Viewers are starting to suspect that John may be revealed as a killer, especially if it’s discovered that Anthony has water in his lungs. If this theory turns out to be true, John could be facing serious consequences as the truth about his involvement in Nate and Anthony’s deaths comes to light.

One fan responded to the theory saying, “I think Nate and Anthony are both in the lake because John put them there. John will turn out to be a killer if they find Anthony has water in his lungs.” This dark twist could add a whole new layer of complexity to John’s character, turning him from a beloved villager into a potential murderer.

What’s Next for the Dales?

With the mystery of the bodies in the lake heating up, Emmerdale viewers are in for a wild ride. The theories surrounding Nate, Anthony, and John are only gaining momentum, and it’s clear that the truth behind the frozen lake is far from simple. Will the villagers uncover the killer, or will more secrets remain buried in the icy waters?

As fans eagerly await the next twist in this gripping storyline, one thing is certain: Emmerdale has another jaw-dropping mystery on its hands, and viewers won’t be able to look away as the drama continues to unfold.