The mystery surrounding Nate Robinson’s shocking death in Emmerdale has left fans scrambling for clues, and a major revelation may have been hiding in plain sight.

With speculation mounting over who was responsible, past episodes could provide the key to unlocking the truth.

The grim discovery of Nate’s body only came to light following the recent limo crash that also claimed the lives of Leyla Harding, Amy Wyatt, and Suzy Merton.

Before Amy tragically perished, she stumbled upon a corpse beneath the lake after falling through the ice.

She appeared convinced it was Nate, identifying significant details before her untimely death prevented her from revealing the information.

Further confirmation followed when Tracy Robinson, Nate’s ex, left him a voicemail, only for the camera to pan to the submerged body, wrapped and weighed down with chains.

The circumstances surrounding his murder remain a mystery, but a closer look at earlier scenes may hold crucial answers.

The Events Leading to Nate’s Disappearance

Before his presumed departure, Nate found himself embroiled in a scandal after being accused of having an affair with his stepmother, Moira Dingle. His father, Cain Dingle, reacted with rage, leading to a violent confrontation. Nate was also left heartbroken when Tracy ended their relationship, refusing to believe in his innocence.

Following these dramatic events, Nate, visibly battered, set out for the farm, intending to confront Moira. However, John Sugden intercepted him, cautioning that he would only escalate the situation. Nate ultimately heeded John’s advice and decided to leave the village, supposedly relocating to Shetland. Strangely, that was the last time he was seen alive.

John was the one who informed the village of Nate’s abrupt departure, and not long after, Tracy received a message from ‘Nate,’ urging her not to contact him. In hindsight, with recent developments revealing that Nate had already been killed, it is now evident that he was never the one sending those texts.

Was John Sugden the Killer All Along?

A crucial episode aired on September 12, shortly after the barn explosion and Nate’s disappearance, may provide the strongest evidence yet that John was responsible for Nate’s death. While most of the characters involved in the farm fire were at the hospital, John remained in the village despite suffering from smoke inhalation.

When Tracy came across John struggling to breathe, she insisted he seek medical attention, prompting Dr. Liam Cavanagh to examine him. However, it was John’s behavior leading up to this moment that raised eyebrows.

Tracy had approached John’s camper van, noting a distinct burning smell. As she neared, John appeared visibly unsettled and hastily shut the van’s side door, leaning against it as if to conceal something. Before noticing Tracy, he had been staring into the van with an expression of anxiety or dread, seemingly contemplating his next move.

This suspicious behavior suggests John may have been preparing to dispose of Nate’s body or crucial evidence when Tracy inadvertently disrupted his plan. Moments later, he attempted to drive off, only to be delayed when Tracy summoned Liam for assistance.

The Timeline of Suspicion

Adding to the intrigue, John was notably absent during the barn explosion, only arriving on the scene later. This absence has led to speculation that he may have used the time to move Nate’s body before returning to the village. His seemingly nonchalant announcement of Nate’s departure to Shetland now appears even more calculated in light of what has been uncovered.

Another telling moment came when John reassured Tracy that Nate was gone, emphasizing his supposed move. When she expressed disappointment at not receiving a proper goodbye, John replied with a simple, “Sorry.” Tracy dismissed his response as innocent, saying, “It’s not your fault, is it?” But what if it was? Could his apology have been an admission of guilt?

The Night Nate’s Body Was Dumped

Flashforward scenes showed Nate’s body being discarded at night, raising the question—did John use the cover of darkness to dispose of the evidence? His growing urgency to leave the village around the same time further fuels speculation. Could his desire to move away have been motivated by guilt and fear of being caught?

While nothing has been confirmed, the mounting evidence against John paints a damning picture. His erratic behavior, mysterious absences, and suspicious movements on the night in question have left Emmerdale fans convinced that he may be the killer.

With the truth yet to be revealed, viewers remain on high alert for any new developments. Was John really behind Nate’s death, or is there another twist waiting to unfold? One thing is for certain—this mystery is far from over.