‘Yellowstone’ Fans Are Seriously Divided After a Major Question Comes Up About the Show

The Yellowstone fandom is in turmoil after news broke that Kevin Costner, who plays the iconic John Dutton, will be leaving the show following the conclusion of season 5.

The split of season 5 into two parts, reportedly without Costner’s knowledge, caused scheduling conflicts with his movie project *Horizon* and ultimately led to his decision to exit the series. With the show’s end now looming, fans have been left wondering: will there be a John Dutton spin-off?

Yellowstone' Fans Are Seriously Divided After a Major Question Comes Up  About the Show - YouTube

This question has ignited heated debates online. Some fans are desperate for a deeper dive into John Dutton’s past, hoping for a prequel starring Josh Lucas, who has already portrayed a young John Dutton in flashbacks.

On Reddit, many are enthusiastic about the idea, with comments like, “Josh Lucas is a good actor, so it wouldn’t be a bad idea,” and “More Josh Lucas is never a bad thing.” Others suggest a ’90s-era series focusing on John’s formative years, believing Lucas could carry the show with less drama and a smaller budget.

Yellowstone' finale divides fans — as 'disaster' ending is compared to  'Game of Thrones'

However, not everyone is on board. Some fans feel the Yellowstone universe is already saturated with spin-offs and prequels. “A few years ago I would have loved this idea, but I just want them to stop now,” one fan wrote.

Another echoed, “The show is built around him. I’m sorry, but no one else can carry the show. It’s just time for it to end.” Some believe the storylines have become lackluster and that the series should conclude with dignity rather than drag on with more sequels or prequels.

Despite the division, series creator Taylor Sheridan is expanding the Yellowstone universe even further. With spin-offs like *1883*, *1923*, and the upcoming *Lawmen: Bass Reeves*, *Yellowstone: 6666*, *1944*, and *1960*, there’s speculation that one of these new shows could explore the roots of John Dutton’s legacy.

While *1944* is rumored to focus on World War II-era Duttons, *1960* may delve into John’s parents’ lives and the era that shaped him. This could provide fans with the backstory they crave, revealing childhood secrets and pivotal moments that made John Dutton the man he is.

Yellowstone' fans are outraged over 'unnecessary' killing spree as series  finale draws near

As for how the current show will connect to these spin-offs, some fans theorize that season 5 part two might end with John Dutton’s death, possibly accompanied by flashbacks to his childhood—setting up a transition to the *1960* series. Meanwhile, characters like Beth and Rip might move on to the *6666* ranch, further expanding the Yellowstone universe.

Another hot topic among fans is the significance of the Yellowstone “Y” brand. Since season 1, branding has symbolized loyalty, commitment, and belonging to the ranch. It’s a painful, almost ritualistic process that marks characters as part of the Dutton family, much like branding cattle.

The origins of this tradition may be explored in *1923* or another spin-off, adding even more depth to the show’s lore.

With Yellowstone set to end in season 5, fans are left divided but eager for answers about the future of the Dutton legacy. Whether or not there’s a John Dutton spin-off, one thing is clear: the world Taylor Sheridan created will continue to captivate audiences for years to come.

Related articles

Taylor Sheridan’s Worst ‘Yellowstone’ Mistake Had Nothing to Do With Kevin Costner, but It Ruined the Franchise’s Best Prequel

Taylor Sheridan’s grandeur of Yellowstone and its plot was overshadowed by the countless plot holes and storylines that Sheridan simply forgot to pick up on during the 5 seasons of this…

Rocco Ran Away From Home, The Kidnapper Appeared While Rocco Was Wandering! GH Spoilers 😱🚨💔

  General Hospital spoilers reveal a heart-wrenching series of events that send shockwaves through Port Charles when two brothers are caught in a web of family secrets,…

DAYS Spoilers Hint That Gwen’s Return Stirs Up Old Secrets on July 8

Days of our Lives spoilers for Tuesday, July 8, reveal Gwen returns to Salem after a long absence, leaving everyone on edge. Julie and Chad are left reeling…

Days of our Lives Spoilers Preview: Gwen’s Back…Plus, Ari Is Stalked

Days of our Lives spoilers photos for the July 8, 2025 episode tease a shockers and stalkers across Salem. Scenes From Salem First, we’ll see Leo (Greg Rikaart) as…

SHOCK EXIT REVEALED!!! Coronation Street legend was desperate to leave: ‘I’m going mad!’

Esteemed actress Anne Reid has said she would’ve ‘gone totally bonkers’ had she stayed in the cast of Coronation Street. The star, 90, who is best known for her roles…

FAMILY TIES Coronation Street fans stunned after realising two stars are real-life mum and son

CORONATION Street fans are stunned after realising two stars are real-life mum and son – and they’ve been hiding in plain sight on the cobbles. From heartwarming…