🩸GOTHIC COMEBACK SHOCKER! 👻🎬 Yellowstone Star’s Forgotten Horror GEM Hits Netflix TOP 10 – And It’s TERRIFYING! 😱🔥

A forgotten gothic nightmare is clawing its way back into the spotlight—thanks to Netflix—and it’s giving even die-hard horror fans goosebumps. The Cursed, a chilling 2021 supernatural tale, has stormed into the platform’s Top 10, reigniting interest in Yellowstone actress Kelly Reilly, who stars in a hauntingly powerful role far removed from her turn as Beth Dutton on the acclaimed Western drama.

Reilly, best known for playing the fierce, no-nonsense Beth—the only daughter of John and Evelyn Dutton—alongside Kevin Costner from 2018 to 2024, proves she’s just as captivating in the realm of horror. While Yellowstone put her on the map for many TV viewers, Reilly’s filmography is more versatile than most fans realize. From her performances in Sherlock Holmes to True Detective, she’s quietly built a reputation as a dynamic actress with a deep emotional range.

But it’s The Cursed—a film that flew under the radar during its initial release—that’s now having a viral second act, showcasing Reilly in a haunting, deeply human role in a story soaked in gothic atmosphere, brutality, and supernatural dread.

The Cursed – A Long-Lost Gothic Gem Resurfaces

Originally released in 2021 under the title Eight for Silver, The Cursed is set in 19th-century rural France, where an isolated village finds itself under siege by an ancient evil. The story follows John McBride (played by Boyd Holbrook), a pathologist investigating a series of brutal, mysterious deaths. Behind the deaths lies something far more terrifying than wild animals—something cursed.

Kelly Reilly takes on the role of Isabelle Laurent, a grieving mother battling both personal demons and supernatural threats. As her family becomes entangled in the horrifying unraveling of a werewolf legend, Reilly anchors the film with a heart-wrenching performance that brings emotional weight to an otherwise nightmarish story.

Her portrayal of Isabelle is nuanced—equal parts strength and sorrow—as she attempts to protect her children from a horror born of vengeance, colonialism, and long-buried secrets. In the hands of lesser talent, the role might have faded into the shadows, but Reilly brings it to life with chilling authenticity.

Streaming Success: A Second Life on Netflix

Though critically praised upon release, The Cursed didn’t make much of a splash at the box office, earning just $4.5 million globally (via Box Office Mojo). Its slow-burn pacing and eerie style likely made it a hard sell in a market saturated with fast-paced jump scares and gore-heavy horror. But now, thanks to Netflix, The Cursed is finally getting the attention it always deserved.

Streaming has become a haven for overlooked gems, and The Cursed proves how quickly audiences can turn a once-ignored release into a sleeper hit. Its climb into Netflix’s Top 10 has sent horror fans into a frenzy, sparking online conversations and renewed praise for its thoughtful storytelling and old-school horror style.

A Unique Take on the Werewolf Mythos

What sets The Cursed apart from your average creature feature is its rich, layered narrative. Rather than focusing solely on the thrill of the hunt, the film explores the origins of its terror. The curse that plagues the village stems from a violent land dispute involving the slaughter of a Romani clan. This act of cruelty becomes the catalyst for the nightmare that unfolds—a moral reckoning wrapped in blood and folklore.

Sean Ellis, who wrote and directed the film, presents a disturbing meditation on guilt, legacy, and vengeance. The cinematography is nothing short of haunting. Fog-drenched forests, candlelit manors, and eerie dream sequences all contribute to a sense of dread that lingers long after the credits roll.

The creature design also deserves praise. Rather than leaning into CGI overload, The Cursed opts for a more practical, physical depiction of horror—one that feels tactile, ancient, and grotesquely real. It’s the kind of horror that seeps into your bones rather than jolting you out of your seat.

Kelly Reilly Shines in the Shadows

As Isabelle Laurent, Kelly Reilly delivers one of her most underrated performances. While Beth Dutton may be the role that cemented her place in pop culture, Isabelle is proof of her dramatic range. She’s not wielding power or delivering razor-sharp comebacks here. Instead, she embodies vulnerability, maternal fear, and quiet determination in the face of unspeakable terror.

Her chemistry with Holbrook adds a layer of emotional complexity to the story, making the viewer care not just about the horror itself, but about the people it threatens. It’s a stark contrast to the relentless pace and surface-level scares found in many modern horror films.

Why Now? Why The Cursed?

So why is The Cursed suddenly trending on Netflix in 2025, nearly four years after its original release?

In part, it’s due to the enduring fanbase of Yellowstone. As audiences dig deeper into the careers of its stars—especially now that the series has concluded—Reilly’s other projects are finding new life. And The Cursed, with its gothic tone and emotionally rich story, is the perfect entry point for those curious about her range beyond Beth Dutton.

It also speaks to a growing hunger for atmospheric horror that prioritizes story over shock. In a time when many horror offerings feel formulaic, The Cursed stands out as something smarter, more elegant, and deeply unsettling.

The Legacy of The Cursed—and What’s Next

As The Cursed continues to gain momentum on Netflix, it’s likely to become a cult classic. It may have started slow, but its resurgence demonstrates that quality storytelling and compelling performances will always find an audience—eventually.

For Kelly Reilly, this renewed attention could usher in a fresh wave of opportunities in genre films. While she’s proven she can hold her own in drama, Westerns, and thrillers, The Cursed reminds viewers that she’s just as powerful in horror.

Whether you’re a horror aficionado or simply a Yellowstone fan curious about Reilly’s darker roles, The Cursed is well worth a watch. It’s eerie, atmospheric, and emotionally resonant—everything a great gothic horror should be.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Miss This One

If you’re scrolling through Netflix in search of something chilling, intelligent, and visually mesmerizing, stop on The Cursed. This long-overlooked gem may not have made waves back in 2021, but in 2025, it’s finally getting its due—and it might just be one of the best horror surprises the platform has to offer.

So dim the lights, brace yourself, and let Kelly Reilly guide you into the shadows of 19th-century terror. You won’t regret it.