Hold on tight, soap fansābecause a Days of Our Lives rumor has just exploded across social media, and it could change everything you thought you knew about Salem. Fan-favorite James Scott, the unforgettable actor behind Elvis “EJ” DiMera, might be headed back to the showābut not as EJ. Instead, whispers suggest Scott could be returning as none other than Stefano DiMera himself. Thatās rightāthe legendary Phoenix may be rising once again⦠in a completely shocking new form.
š„ James Scott’s Unmatched Legacy as EJ DiMera
Letās rewind for a moment. When James Scott first appeared in Days of Our Lives in 2006 as the slick, magnetic EJ DiMera, fans instantly fell under his spell. With his suave British charm, piercing intensity, and ruthless DiMera family ambition, Scott delivered one of the most iconic performances in the show’s history. His on-screen chemistry with Alison Sweeneyās Sami Brady created an unforgettable supercoupleāequal parts passion, danger, and heartbreak.
From corporate takeovers and family betrayal to deep love and tragic death, EJās story arc was packed with unforgettable highs and devastating lows. His supposed death in 2014 shocked fans and left Sami devastated. While the character was resurrected off-screen and eventually recast with Dan Feuerriegel, many longtime viewers never stopped longing for Scottās return.
But what if EJ wasnāt the role heād come back for?
š± The Shocking Twist: James Scott as Stefano?!
Thatās the rumor currently swirling around Days of Our Lives fan circles. With the show teasing a possible resurrection of Stefano DiMeraāoriginally played to perfection by the late Joseph Mascoloāsome fans believe James Scott could take up the mantle. Yes, the Phoenix might rise again⦠this time in the body of his own son.
It may sound far-fetched, but letās not forgetāweāre talking about Days of Our Lives, where mind control, devil possession, and brain transplants have all made prime-time appearances. Remember when Stefanoās essence was implanted into Steve āPatchā Johnsonās body? In Salem, no storyline is too outlandish.
So, what if history repeats itself?
𧬠A DiMera Twist Worthy of the Ages
Imagine this: EJ, presumed to be himself, begins behaving oddlyāstrategizing with renewed ruthlessness, reviving DiMera Enterprises with terrifying efficiency, and echoing Stefanoās most famous lines. Slowly, Sami, Chad, and others around him begin to suspect something sinister is at play. Then comes the bombshellāStefano’s consciousness has taken over EJās body.
James Scottāchanneling both his iconic EJ role and the sinister mastermind traits of Stefanoāwould redefine villainy in Salem. It would be a stunning twist that reinvigorates the DiMera legacy while giving fans the dramatic return theyāve been craving.
And Scott has everything it takes to pull it off.
Heās already shown the charisma, menace, and complexity that defined Stefano. Pair that with his emotional depth and longstanding connection to the show, and you have the recipe for a sensational comeback.
š¬ But Thereās One Huge Obstacle…
James Scott himself.
In 2020, Scott took to social media to declare that he had no intention of returning to Days of Our Livesāor Hollywood at all. His statement was emphatic: āNever, never, never.ā Since stepping away from the spotlight, Scott has shifted his focus to a more peaceful life, including a spiritual coaching practice called The Whisper Within. Heās kept a low profile and expressed a desire to move on from acting altogether.
This makes any potential return feel like a long shot. But as any seasoned soap fan will tell you: never say never.
š„ Could the Right Role Bring Him Back?
Letās be realāreturning as EJ might not have appealed to Scott. But returning as Stefano? Thatās a whole different story. A role steeped in legacy, power, and high-stakes drama. The chance to reinvent one of the most iconic villains in soap opera history might be the only thing dramatic enough to entice him.
After all, this wouldnāt just be a comeback. It would be a reinvention. A seismic twist that could shake up Days as it heads into its 60th anniversary in 2025.
And fans are ready.
š£ļø Fan Reactions and Theories: The Internet is Buzzing
On Reddit, X (formerly Twitter), and soap forums everywhere, fans are going wild. Some are begging for Scottās return, calling it āthe comeback of the decade.ā Others are cautiously optimistic, acknowledging his past comments but still hoping the showrunners have found a way to lure him back.
One popular theory suggests Stefanoās return wonāt be physical, but rather a psychological possession. Perhaps EJ isnāt even aware heās being influenced by his fatherās essenceāsetting the stage for a heart-wrenching battle between EJās true self and the emerging Stefano persona.
And donāt forget Sami. Can you imagine the emotional turmoil if she realizes the love of her life has been overtaken by her greatest enemy? Itās a drama goldmine that would put even Marlenaās devil storyline to shame.
š” What If Itās Not Scott?
Of course, itās entirely possible that Scott really wonāt returnāand the show could go another direction. Other actors are being considered for a potential Stefano recast, including soap legends like Vincent Irizarry or Robert Kelker-Kelly. Thereās even speculation about a younger actor being introduced through some wild aging twist or clone experiment.
But none of them bring the same symbolic weight, the legacy connection, or the sheer fan passion that James Scott does.
šļø A Tribute to Joseph Mascoloāand a New Chapter
Thereās no replacing Joseph Mascolo. His portrayal of Stefano was a masterclass in soap villainy, and his legacy still looms large. But perhaps thatās the point. Bringing back Stefano through a new vesselāespecially one as connected to the character as James Scottācould honor that legacy while opening a bold new chapter.
Think of it as passing the torchāfrom father to son, both on-screen and off.
šŗ What Happens Next?
Right now, itās all speculation. But the buzz is loud, and the timing feels right. Days of Our Lives is no stranger to headline-making twists, and a Phoenix reborn in the body of his own son would be one for the history books.
So, what do you think? Could James Scott actually return to Salem as Stefano DiMera? Would you welcome a mind-blowing twist like this, or is the idea too out thereāeven for Days?
One thing is certain: the fires of fan speculation are burning hotter than ever. And if the Phoenix is about to rise⦠weāll be watching every moment.
Stay tuned. š„ššļø